[Barachiel]

If you don't care, why read the thread? This is KI, I can bellyache all I want about the idiocy, and I can argue for my point if I so choose. If you don't like it then skip over my posts, any post that doesn't agree with you, or better yet ignore the entire thread and continue to live in your own happy world where everyone agrees with you.

At this point it's 50/50. Or more like 70/30. Logic and good business practice says dancer will be male/female, while history says it will be female only. Imo, the first two trump the third, but SE may pull a fast one.

[Kussese]

Sugami :

Kussese[/b]]
Look at the male taru playing the guitar. If this does happen to be a female only job, my guess if that they'll implement a second instrument job for males only.

Hey, guess what? There's already a job that plays instruments, it's called "Bard".

Hey, guess what? You can't read an entire post through with out flaming it! :dontgetit

[Wildiecardie]

I don't read Japanese but I do understand some of their words since Japanese language consists of some Chinese Characters. I switch to the JP Playonline websites and the topic reads "Goddess of the Battlefield - Dancer" which makes me believe that Dancer should probably be female only. (and possibly Viking be male only.)

As for the Necromancer idea, I am not familiar with Old FF game and from what I read from the JP Playonline, it did mention about raising the skeletons with dances. I am kinda hoping for a AOE raise 1 skill which maybe useful for situations like Dynamis and stuff.

[Static]

I think a lot of you are taking this page in history a little too litterally. If the history lessons explained how these jobs are supposed to be played then wheres my cors pirate ship?

[Corrderio]

I posted this in the FFXI Info thing, but the only reason it's probably called miaden/heroine is because those events happened mainly during the main war, and what else would the men be doing? Getting hammered at the tavern? Hell no, they were taking up arms and participating in the war.

[Sugami]

Kussese :
Hey, guess what? You can't read an entire post through with out flaming it! :dontgetit

Hey, guess what? That wasn't a flame.

I did read it, kinda late but the point still remains. What's the point in having two BRD jobs?

[NinjaGorge]

I posted this in the FFXI Info thing, but the only reason it's probably called miaden/heroine is because those events happened mainly during the main war, and what else would the men be doing? Getting hammered at the tavern? Hell no, they were taking up arms and participating in the war.

That is true:

San D'orian history, Elvaan woman were not involved or allowed in wars for sometime.

Logic and good business practice says dancer will be male/female, while history says it will be female only. Imo, the first two trump the third, but SE may pull a fast one.

This person wins 5 "You're winner" trophies as shown in my sig.

[Yoona]

This isn't real life though. You can't really say that because in real life in the past women stayed at home while the men went off to war that the same thing happened in vana diel. I'm sure that men and women are equal in windurst, and women might be more powerful because of the mithra, and the fact that the leader (star sybil) is a girl. So one of the three nations often didn't allow the women to go to war? Look at the expansion packs. All three have had women protagonists and male antagonists. Lion was hot and she saved the world. Prishe was pretty tough especially if you've beaten the last mission. Aphmau you really can't count because first of all shes 16 I think, and secondly *Spoilers* [grey]shes the empress of the Aht Urghan Empire[/grey] so you really can't expect her to be in any really dangerous situations.

[Corrderio]

Even so, at least my theory is logical compared to the "It's female only becuase this topic said so" bullshit. And yes, I seen females in the CS, but most of them were mithra.

[MIR The Great]

Before this article there's never been any good reason to think Dancer would be Female only, but now the way this job is described really makes people thinks that Dancer is female.

Someone at SE must be seriously out of his mind.

If Dancer is not going to be female only, then they are absolutely crazy making a job description that only mention "maidens" and such without any reference to male dancers.

If Dancer is going to be female only, then they are still out of their mind for barring half of the players from selecting a job. And making another job, male only, with the same abilities is not a solution, is retarded.