Funny, i've been in this game for over 5 years, and I will admit... I troll these message boards everyday out of boredom at work. It's sad that THIS is the post that made me sign up to reply... but for good reason!
Ok, here's my long reply...
and WARNING... it's pretty long winded
When it comes to DNC, I will never disput that it has it's place. I'm not here to argue the damage, or it's versitility yada yada yada...
My complaint and experience comes from this:
unless DNC is you ONLY 75... i guarantee to have something better to bring to the table when it comes to merit parties.
Please don't sit around and complain that you can't get an invite if you have at least ONE other useful job that can get invited twice if not three times as fast.
ME? my mains are RNG and COR (both 75)... and i hate waiting around and/or meriting on my RNG.
If i want Merits, the COR flag goes up, and *poof* insta-invite.
Make a bunch of merits. spend whereever i see fit. wash, rinse, repeat.
That solves that problem.
or...does it...?
Alu and I are leaders of our Endgame shell... and our bitterness seems to spawn from the obnoxious amount of "DNC Goes" we get surrounded by on a daily basis. This goes hand in hand with the "If you have a more appropriate job... BRING IT" idea as explained above in my merit rant. Watch... here's some examples:
A former member of ours had WHM, PLD, DRG, BRD and RDM at 75... the second their DNC hit 65-70... ALL we heard was "DNC Goes"
Hey!!! We're doing gods tonight!!!
DNC Goes?
...no...
COME ON!!! UFO Farming!!!!
DNC GOES?
...god no...
w00t! We're gonna punch babies in the face and take their candy!!!
DNC GOES!?!?!?
...please stop...
Every step of the way... wether we were picking our noses or Doing Sea/Sky DNC GOES plagued us.
FIVE other jobs that could have worked out astronomicaly better... yet DNC was insisted upon until we shunned them.
it wouldn't stop.
See where i'm coming from on this?
YES you may enjoy your new Job-Candy... but that doesn't mean EVERYONE has too.
Next Example:
Someone was APPLYING to our Shell.
When asked what jobs they had to bring to the table... they replied: NIN, THF, RDM, WHM... and DNC
We asked them to bring RDM:
sorry, I only solo with RDM
Asked to bring WHM:
sorry, its retired
Asked to bring THF:
Sorry, you'll want TH4 and I no gots it
Finally asked to bring NIN:
hmm... I don't think your shell will benefit from my NIN. Sorry, I'm gonna pass
Those are the HONEST answers we got.
Seriously WTF ?? WHY list 4 OTHER JOBS that are better suited to our needs??
Cause they are trying to disguise DNC in their usefulness.
Bottom Line:
Don't get butthurt if people don't want your DNC.
I'm not knockin its usefulness
i'm not crappin on its Damage or Abilities
I'm just stating... IF you have somethign more useful... use it.
...or retire it, sell you gear, and DNC ONRY!!!...
DNC DOES have its place...
It a nice safe distance away from me in Endgame
Who's to say what's more useful unless it's blatantly obvious. It's all really situational. If someone has Paladin and you NEED a tank but they insist on going Dancer I feel you there, we sometimes get that and it's annoying because in low man stuff every person has to be on their proper role (not job, role.) Meaning we have a designated Tank (it could be a Paladin, it could be a Rdm, hell it could even be a Blue Mage) and we need a healer (Red Mage, White Mage, Scholar, etc.) Situationally I'd say Red Mage is usually the better healer by themself but if someone really doesn't want to play a job they're gonna intentionally suck at it or not be as enthusiastic to do their shit right and that can affect the entire event as a whole. But, this is my point of view on things and I feel that people should be happy playing the jobs they want to play and if the need requires them to be a certain thing they either have to change to the necessary job or make the job they want to play fitted to perform what is asked of them. If that isn't possible then "sorry bro but you're changing to White mage!"
Eh, probably said some unnecessary stuff in there but! Basically if the person is doing their job well who are you to say that "insert job" is better? If they aren't doing their job and "insert job" would definitely be better then I can see why you get flustered about it. Again, it all comes down to how the player performs or if the situation is ridiculously obvious that a different job is necessary.
As for the person that responded to you with those turrible excuses that happens quite a bit, not even with just dancer. People with a ton of jobs will have a job that they really do NOT feel like playing or bringing out anymore. For me, it is red mage. (But my main reason is I have 8 Blue magic and 8 elemental magic so Enfeeb = 0, makes me feel hella gimp.) It'd be better to say you get angry at the people who "level jobs and then hide them behind their favorite job so they can have fun at the expense of a successul event."
edit: forgot my picture