Sera said:
I don't think path is necessarily asking you what a girl has to smell like for you to put it IN her, I think he's trying to ask you what smell makes you smile about the memory of it for years afterwards.
Patrick was asking for us to circle jerk about our individual Pavlovian responses? Queerly uncharacteristic for him...besides, he'll probably be along in a jiffy to point out how "smiling about the memory of it for years" is just some sort of vaginal hogwash that your feeble, emotive, irrational female mind has spawned, which flies in the immortal face of the unflinching steel of man-reason.
pathwriter said:
I'm not suggesting that Mary Worth is going to turn into Megan Fox (or whoever you think is attractive) by wearing perfume, but I refuse to believe that you guys are totally unaffected by smell. Humans may not have a dog's olfactory competence, but we do react strongly to scents. I'm sure you could name a dozen sorts of perfume that you do not favor and that, if smelled, would make you think twice about a given woman. You might not throw her out in the cold for it, but you're not unconscious of its noxious nature.
And my suggestion that our olfactory sense acts in an exclusionary manner so far as attractiveness is concerned denies your conclusion how, exactly? I think a great many things smell nice, but whether I find fragrances sensually attractive or not is primarily based on previous relationships, and secondarily, as an accidental ascription to an already-attractive woman's halo effect upon first contact with her.
I guess for the sake of human physiology I should admit that I find the smell of particular pheromones irresistible.