[Ezekial]

True in a way, but any highly resistant monster I have come across where there has also been a Corsair that gears in MACC over AGI I have beaten. That is easily enough proof for me.

[Nath]

How can u gear extensively in MAcc over AGI? I mean the only slot of my gear that is Macc > AGI is omega ring.... Furthermore all i can think of off the top of my head would be some retard picking the +4macc > +4 MaB on AcP body, although there may be other things i cant think of

Merits, freak resists, difference in SJ, difference in quality of gear

All these must be taken into account too before you make these frankly, stupid statements and compare yourself to other Corsair

[Daiiawn_]

Ezekial, on 15 November 2009 - 05:44 PM, said:

True in a way, but any highly resistant monster I have come across where there has also been a Corsair that gears in MACC over AGI I have beaten. That is easily enough proof for me.

That doesnt mean shit. My point stands. Go shoot tiamat 20-30 times without warlocks roll, and then shoot it 20-30 times with warlocks roll and try telling me you dont see a difference. Beating corsairs who are geared for macc on highly resistant stuff doesnt really mean much, because if the agil:macc ratio is anything like the int:macc ratio on blm, in most slots agil would be better on something resistant. Dont get me wrong, im not saying agil is shit gear macc, im saying you are a idiot for a: saying macc doesnt make a difference and b: thinking that a screenshot showing all of what? 2 QD's from you? is evidence.

I honestly find it outstanding that any corsair who is well aware that MAGIC attack bonus affects QD, can argue that MAGIC accuracy bonus does not. I may as well go over to the blm forums and post hey guyz!!! Macc only affects enfeebles yo!.

[Antithesis]

Tarutaru have more AGI than most other races.


I SMELL FOUL PLAY

[RUebyy]

Yea uh. Macc helps QD >_>. shot off about 50 shots last night during ballista and noticed a dmg increase from about 360-380 w.o warlocks to 404 consistantly w/ warlocks on (on different occasions might i add). was shooting the same person.

Ballista is an easy way to test out Macc/agi vs QD dmg since all the stats in the equation are easily measurable and you can get some form of control in your experiments. You can do it yourselves to see but i'll look up some things and do a recorded/documentd experiment in diorama later on and post some ressults here.

This post has been edited by RUebyy: 19 March 2010 - 05:38 PM

[Corrderio]

And this deserved a bump?

[RUebyy]

oh dayum i didn't even take note of how old it was, i assumed it was relevant because i still see nay-sayers posting about macc today

[Corrderio]

It's cool. I'm just sick of how this topic seems to come up once every 2-3 months.

[RUebyy]

i could imagine. i still think imma do those tests tho, even if only for my own confirmation.

[Corrderio]

Well I'd say it's pretty much proven. I am however curious if SE ninja fixed QD damage though. Since I noticed odd spikes in my damage.

[RUebyy]

Spike's on things like what? I've only been COR75 a couple weeks now but i had it almost completely geared before hand.

[Corrderio]

I dunno, sometimes I seem to get a random jump in damage. I'm not sure why. It's not a weather effect I'm pretty sure on that.